Today's Mishnah Yomi
Bava Basra 9:9 - 9:10
The Mishnah Yomi for Saturday, December 14, 2024 is Bava Basra 9:9 - 9:10
Mishnah 1
Change text layout:
Mishnayos Bava Basra Perek 9 Mishnah 9
בבא בתרא פרק ט׳ משנה ט׳
Bartenura
האשה מתה תחילה. ואין ליורשי האשה כלום, שהרי הבעל מת אחרון וירש את אשתו:
נכסים בחזקתן. נכסי צאן ברזל בחזקתן. ולא פירשו בית הלל אי בחזקת יורשי האשה שהיו שלה, אי בחזקת יורשי הבעל שאחריותן עליו, הלכך נכסי צאן ברזל יחלוקו:
וכתובת אשה. שהם מנה מאתים ותוספת, נשארים בחזקת יורשי הבעל:
ונכסים הנכנסים ויוצאים עמה. הם נכסי מלוג. שבשעה שהיא נכנסת נכנסים עמה וכשהיא יוצאת יוצאים עמה. אם פחתו פחתו לה ואם הותירו הותירו לה. אלו הם בחזקת יורשי האשה. נמצאו יורשי האשה נוטלים כל נכסי מלוג וחצי נכסי צאן ברזל:
Mishnah 2
Mishnayos Bava Basra Perek 9 Mishnah 10
בבא בתרא פרק ט׳ משנה י׳
Bartenura
נפל הבית עליו ועל אמו – and she has no other son other than this one. The inheritors of the son say that the woman died first and the son inherited her property and we inherit the son. But the inheritors of the woman from the family of the house of her father state that the son died first and that we inherit the woman.
אלו ואלו מודים [ – The School of Shammai and the School of Hillel [agree] that they should divide it. But this is not like the case where the house fell upon him and his wife. For in that case, there are two types of property. There is what the husband is in possession of and there is what the wife is in possession of, but here, everything is in the possession of the woman/wife since she was a widow. And both come from the power of inheritance to inherit everything. Therefore, it is divided.
מודה אני בזה – for according to the words of the School of Hillel, we say that is so that the property is left in the hands of the possessors, in the possession of her inheritors from the father’s side, for during her lifetime, once her husband died she is a connected through the tribe of her father. And her monies also during her lifetime are in the possession of her father’s tribe. Therefore, her inheritors from the father’s side inherit her, and the Halakha is according to Rabbi Akiba.
על חלוקין אנו מצטערין – meaning to say, on the disagreement above of the Schools of Shammai and Hillel. We are saddened that they didn’t come to agreement and you say that also with this they are divided. And you came to dispute on the first Tanna/teacher, that they are both equivalent.
נפל הבית עליו ועל אמו. ואין לה בן אחר אלא זה. יורשי הבן אומרים האשה מתה תחלה וירש הבן נכסיה ואנו יורשים הבן. ויורשי האשה ממשפחת בית אביה אומרים הבן מת תחלה ואנו יורשים את האשה:
אלו ואלו מודים. ב״ש וב״ה שיחלוקו. דכיון ששניהם באים מכח ירושה הוי ספק וספק ויחלוקו. ולא דמי לנפל הבית עליו ועל אשתו, דהתם יש שני מיני נכסים, יש שהבעל מוחזק ויש שהאשה מוחזקת, אבל הכא הכל בחזקת האשה כיון שהיתה אלמנה, ושניהם באים מכח ירושה לירש הכל, הלכך יחלוקו:
מודה אני בזה. דלדברי בית הלל הכא נמי אמרינן נכסים בחזקתן, בחזקת יורשיה מן האב, שהרי בחייה משמת בעלה אחר שבט אביה היא מתיחסת, וממונה נמי בחייה היה בחזקת שבט אביה. הלכך יורשיה מן האב יורשים אותה. והלכה כרבי עקיבא:
על החלוקין אנו מצטערין. כלומר, על מחלוקת דלעיל דב״ש וב״ה אנו מצטערים שלא השוו דעתן, ואתה אומר שגם בזה חלוקין ובאת לחלוק על תנא קמא שאומר שהם שוין:
Mishnah Yomi FAQ
What is Mishnah Yomi?
Mishnah Yomi is a daily study program where participants study two mishnayot (individual teachings from the Mishnah) every day. By following this program, one can complete the entire Mishnah in about six years.
What is the Mishnah?
The Mishnah is the first major written collection of Jewish oral traditions, forming the basis of the Talmud. It dates back to around 200 CE and consists of teachings and discussions of Jewish law by various rabbis.
Who started the Mishnah Yomi program?
In 1934, the Kozoglover Gaon, Rav Aryeh Tzvi Frommer, who took over from Rav Meir Shapiro (the founder of Daf Yomi) as the head of Yeshivas Chachmei Lublin, initiated the Mishnah Yomi cycle, focusing on Seder Zeraim and Seder Taharos. After World War II, in 1947, Rav Yonah Sztencl, a disciple of Rav Frommer, expanded the program, advocating for a comprehensive study of Shishah Sidrei Mishnah. The idea of studying two Mishnayos daily gained the support of figures like Rav Isser Zalman Meltzer, the Tchebiner Rov, and the Gerer Rebbe, marking the formal inception of Mishnah Yomi.
How long does it take to complete the Mishnah with Mishnah Yomi?
Following the Mishnah Yomi program, one can complete the Mishnah in approximately six years.
Can anyone join Mishnah Yomi?
Yes, anyone interested in studying the Mishnah can start the Mishnah Yomi cycle. There’s no need for prior knowledge; beginners are welcome.
Do I need to know Hebrew to study Mishnah Yomi?
While the Mishnah is originally in Hebrew, there are numerous translations and commentaries available in various languages, making it accessible to anyone interested in studying.
Is there a specific time of day to study Mishnah Yomi?
There’s no designated time. Participants can choose a time that best fits their schedule.
Can I study Mishnah Yomi with a group?
Yes, many communities and synagogues organize group study sessions for Mishnah Yomi. Studying in a group can enhance understanding and foster camaraderie.
What if I miss a day?
If you miss a day, you can catch up by studying the missed mishnayot alongside the current day’s study or by dedicating some extra time until you’re back on track.
האשה מתה תחלה – and there is nothing for the inheritors of the wife, for the husband died last and inherited his wife.
נכסים בחזקתן – mort-main (i.e., wife’s estate held by her husband, which in case of her death or divorce he must restore “in specie,” being responsible with all his landed property for loss or deterioration) belongs to present occupants but the School of Hillel did not explain if it is in the possession of the inheritors of the wife which were hers or in the possession of the inheritors of the husband for their responsibility is upon him. Therefore, the mort-main is to be divided.
וכתובת אשה – which are a Maneh (= 100 silver denars) or two hundred (denars) and a supplement which remain in the possession of the inheritors of the husband.
ונכסים הנכנסים והיוצאים עמה – these are the usufruct (i.e., the wife’s estate of which the husband has the fruition without responsibility for loss or deterioration) for at the time that she enters [into marriage], they enter with her, and if they lessened, they lessen for her, and if they increased, they increased for her, it is found that the inheritors of the wife take all the usufruct and half of the mort-main.